Has anyone used ilovepdf vs smallpdf vs pdf2go vs mergepdf?

I’m a freelancer who needs to merge and compress client PDFs a few times a week, and I keep seeing these four online tools mentioned everywhere. Has anyone actually used more than one of them, and which held up best with bigger files and free limits?

I merge scanned worksheets weekly and ilovepdf has handled bigger files best for me. Smallpdf’s free limit runs out fast, and pdf2go feels ad-heavy.

I had the same issue with tenant forms, and the free limits on those sites changed often enough that I stopped relying on them for bigger files. I use Preview on Mac to merge and export a smaller copy, but I check that scanned text stays readable.

Yeah, the free limits are the real headache with bigger files. I tried a couple of them a while back, they were fine for one-offs but hit limits fast when I had a stack of 50MB+ client docs. These days I just use whats already on my computer.

Juggling all those different tools is honestly so frustrating when you just want to get your work done. I deal with endless receipts and invoices for bookkeeping, and I find ilovepdf is the most reliable for combining bulky files. To be fair, Smallpdf has a nice layout, but you hit their free limit much faster. Try starting with ilovepdf and see how your client documents handle it.

@kind_yeti I’ve had about the same experience with intake packets. I use iLovePDF for the occasional big merge, then open the finished file and spot-check a few pages before sending it. On my old clinic PC, that saves me from waiting on a bulky desktop program.

  1. I run ilovepdf for merging newsletter pages, holds up fine even with image heavy files, free limit hasnt been an issue for weekly use.
  2. Smallpdf compresses a bit better in my experience but daily free task limit is tighter.
  3. If you need batch stuff regular, worth looking at a desktop tool too so your not capped by free tiers.

I stopped bouncing between those web toys after one too many ‘free’ limits. Easiest for me is PDFcap: drag the files in to merge, then run compress before emailing. On my old laptop it handles big scanned claim packets locally, so nothing sits on someone else’s server. If a file still fights back, I try printing to PDF first.

@sneaky_grandpa that’s a good way to handle it. I mostly stick with what’s already on my computer too. When a PDF gives me trouble, I open it in a viewer and print to PDF, that usually fixes the size. Which system are you running that on?

I’ve used a couple, but free limits and upload speeds changed often, so I wouldn’t pick based on size claims alone. For client files I usually merge in Preview on my Mac, then use Print > PDF to make a smaller copy; tip: keep the originals, and avoid uploading anything confidential, tbh.